617.209.2224

CLIENT PORTAL

ADVISORS

Will AI Replace Financial Advisors?

by Benjamin Beck, CFP® Benjamin Beck, CFP® | November 17, 2026

Will AI replace financial advisors?

Maybe it will replace some of them. In fact, I think it should. But the information was never the hard part. Behavior is the hard part. And the truly great advisors were never valuable because they knew some secret that nobody else knew. They were valuable because they knew you.

A few years ago, I took the family down to New York City to see Back to the Future, which was playing on Broadway at the time, and it was just awesome. Part of what made it so great was my kids getting to experience something that had been a huge part of my life growing up, and probably all of our lives.

You had Biff, you had the DeLorean, you had Marty. And all those years later, watching this story come alive on stage with my own family brought me right back to my growing-up years.

Recently I caught myself thinking about the movie and the play for a totally different reason. In Back to the Future, Marty has accidentally been sent back to 1955, and his teenage father, George, is about to get hit by a car. Marty jumps in, pushes him out of the way, and saves him.

Seems like a pretty good decision. Except George was supposed to get hit by the car. That accident was supposed to lead to Lorraine, Marty’s future mom, taking care of George, and eventually they would fall in love. Instead, Marty gets hit, Lorraine takes care of him, and in one of the stranger situations in 1980s movies, Marty’s teenage mother starts developing a crush on him.

Marty unknowingly changed the course of his own life, and pretty soon the consequences started showing up. If you remember, there’s a photograph he carries around of himself and his siblings, and his brother and his sister start disappearing from the picture. If Marty can’t somehow get George and Lorraine together at the dance, eventually Marty disappears too.

The brilliance of the whole thing is that Marty doesn’t make some obvious, insane decision. He sees his father about to get hit by a car, he reacts, he does what feels right in the moment, and he almost destroys his entire future. There’s a lesson in there that has absolutely nothing to do with time travel.

Human beings are really, really good at reacting. We are much less naturally equipped to understand all of the consequences that are downstream from those actions. And that’s one of the reasons advice matters versus information. Advice versus information: there’s a difference.

Information vs. Advice

I was reminded of that recently while thinking about a project my wife and I did a few years ago, when we were putting a little bit of an outdoor screened-in room off the back of our house. We had spent a lot of time looking at websites like Houzz and seeing these unbelievable outdoor living spaces, mostly in the warmer climates, but nonetheless: retractable screens that disappear into the structure, TVs, outdoor kitchens, all that stuff.

Our contractor came over to help us design a space that would work for us, and he gave us all kinds of information: the square footage, the materials, the countertops, all the combinations of where everything could go and what the retractable screens would look like.

At some point I told him I wanted, or at the time thought I wanted, an elaborate surround sound system. And of course I did. If we’re building a room outside, we might as well do it right. So I asked him how he would design it, all the details, and he told me. He explained where the speakers would go, all the equipment that would be needed, which brands would work better than others, and, since everything was outside, what it would take to install everything properly.

That was information. Then he said something completely different. He said, “You know, Ben, I wouldn’t do that right now. You can absolutely put a sound system in, and I’ll put it in at some point. But I think if it’s going to add a meaningful amount of money to this project, which it is, I don’t think you’re going to get the value out of it that you think you will. Let’s face it, we’re in Massachusetts. We’re not sitting outside, unfortunately, 12 months out of the year. The TV is going to produce plenty of sound for what you’re looking for. Why don’t you just finish the room, live in it for a year, have some experience with it, and if you’re still hell-bent on all these little bells and whistles, we can come back and do it then. That’s no big deal.”

Now, that was advice, and there was a gigantic difference. Information answered the question I asked: how do I put in the surround sound, and what should I put in here? Advice answered the question: should I actually be putting it in this room at all? And even more importantly, he talked himself out of a lot of potential revenue.

That’s when you know you’re dealing with someone who’s actually advising you. He could have simply taken my order. A lot of contractors would have just added it to the work order and gone on with it. He didn’t. He didn’t allow my enthusiasm to get out of control.

If Your Advisor’s Value Is Information

That’s one of the reasons I find the current conversation around artificial intelligence and financial advisors so interesting. There is a growing hypothesis that AI will eventually replace financial advisors, and a lot of other things. And maybe it will replace some of them. In fact, I think it should.

But I also think the argument exposes how deeply people misunderstand what the value of a true financial advisor actually is. Because if your advisor’s primary value proposition is information, AI should scare the living daylights out of you.

Seriously. If an advisor’s job is to tell people over and over again what the S&P 500 returns, or how much you should save, or the differences between a Roth IRA and a traditional IRA, or to run a retirement plan projection or explain a 529 plan, all those different things, AI is going to be extraordinarily good at that. It will continue to get better, and in many cases it already has.

It can access enormous amounts of information almost instantly. It can calculate, compare, model, summarize, all these things. We have those at our fingertips today within our firm, and it’s fantastic. That should concern anybody whose entire value proposition is being the person with the information. But that was never the value proposition of a great advisor.

Behavior Is the Hard Part

The foundational value of financial advice is behavioral. It is emotional. It is helping another human being do what they need to do with their money when every human instinct inside them is telling them to do what they want to do. Those are two very, very different things.

Think about almost every financially responsible decision we make. Successful investing requires, to a great extent, the deferral of gratification. Save the money instead of spending it. Max out the 401(k) instead of buying the boat. Spend a few extra dollars on the life insurance instead of upgrading the car. Keep investing when the market feels terrible. Don’t chase whatever your neighbor might have made money on. Don’t sell the thing that is temporarily declining simply because watching it decline is painful. Don’t make a permanent decision because of a temporary emotion.

None of this is particularly difficult to understand, like right now, as we’re talking about it. The information is not the hard part. Behavior is the hard part.

Marty Needed Doc

If we go back to Back to the Future, Marty eventually understands exactly what’s going to happen. He sees his brother disappearing from the photograph. He understands that his parents have to fall in love. He has the information. But now he needs somebody who can help him think through the situation without the same emotional baggage, and that’s Doc Brown.

Doc has the perspective. He has the experience. He sees the consequences, and throughout the movie he is extraordinarily cautious about changing the future. When Marty tries to give the younger Doc information about what will happen to him in 1985, Doc initially refuses to hear it, because he’s afraid that knowledge of the future itself could alter events.

Doc isn’t valuable because Marty doesn’t have the facts. He’s valuable because he can help Marty understand what those facts mean. And that’s advice.

One Terrifying Tuesday Afternoon

Now, let’s take the stakes up significantly. Imagine going back to March of 2020. COVID is spreading, the world’s shutting down, and nobody knows how bad it’s going to get. The stock market is falling violently. You’ve spent 30 or even 40 years building your retirement savings, and every day you log in and see an enormous chunk of your life’s work financially disappear. You call your financial advisor and say, “Get me out. Sell it. I can’t do this anymore.”

What information, exactly, are you missing? You know the market is falling. You know your account values are lower than they were the day before. You can look up what the S&P 500 is doing. You can read about past bear markets. You can study historical returns. You can ask an artificial intelligence system to show you every major decline that’s happened in the last 100 years and what happened afterward.

None of that is really why you’re making the call. You are scared. You’re looking for relief. And selling gives you something incredibly seductive in that moment: at least temporarily, it feels like the pain stops. That’s the moment where financial advice has the most value.

Your advisor might have to say, “No. I know exactly why you want to sell. I know this feels awful. I know every instinct in your body right now is telling you to protect what you have left. But we have planned for this. We talked about this. And I’m not going to let you blow up 30 years of planning because of how you feel one terrifying Tuesday afternoon.”

Now, that’s not information. That’s advice.

Can AI Give Financial Advice?

Could artificial intelligence technically say those same words? Actually, it just did. I put this scenario into ChatGPT and said, “Talk to me like a really, really good financial advisor,” and those lines I just said are what it actually spit out. It can show you the history. It can generate an amazingly persuasive argument.

But human financial advice at its highest level is not simply about generating the correct sentence. It’s about how, and whether, the sentence lands. Does the person you’re sitting across from believe you? Do they trust you? Have you had enough of a body of work with them, accumulated enough credibility over the past 10 or 15 years, that they believe you when you say, “I know this hurts, but don’t do it”?

Can you recognize the difference between someone who is asking for information and someone who is actually terrified? Can you hear what they aren’t saying? Can you understand how their spouse, sitting next to them, feels? Can you understand the history of maybe their parents losing all of their money in terrible business or financial circumstances years and years ago? That’s part of their psyche.

The relationship matters. In fact, I think the financial interaction becomes more genuine with a human being. Possessing the information is less valuable. Judgment, trust, and human connection are the most important part.

Why Pay an Advisor?

We’ve actually seen versions of this argument before, years ago. Things came along like no-load mutual funds: why pay an advisor when I can buy the investments myself? Index funds, and that one still happens all the time: why pay an advisor when I can just own the S&P 500 by myself and really pay nothing? Robo-advisors showed up a few years ago: why pay an advisor when a computer can build and rebalance a portfolio for almost nothing? That’s just information. Now we call it artificial intelligence: why pay an advisor when AI can do more of what an advisor can do?

If all your advisor is doing is providing you information, then that’s a really great argument. And frankly, we do need fewer of those people in our industry anyway.

There is an important exception, though, where the line of reasoning around AI replacing advisors is pretty irrefutable, and it’s when the advisor in question has no freaking value proposition to begin with. If the family doesn’t perceive the advice as having real value, then of course every bad advisor is vulnerable, to AI or anything else for that matter: no-load mutual funds, index funds, robo-advisors, all of that. Because it’s not advice. It’s information.

They Knew You

The truly great advisors were never valuable because they knew some secret that nobody else knew. They were valuable because they knew you, and that’s a radically different thing.

My contractor knew me. He knew all the things about how to install speakers, or whatever it was. Doc Brown understood time travel, but his value to Marty was helping him think through the consequences Marty couldn’t see clearly. A great financial advisor understands all these things about investments and taxes and estate planning, but the highest expression of that knowledge is not being able to recite it. It’s being able to apply it to a real human being in the moment that human being is most likely to sabotage themselves.

And I think that makes the future of great advice more exciting, not less. The more human-like technology becomes available, the more valuable it is to be a human being. Humans relate to other human beings they can trust, that they can look in the eyes when they come looking for answers. The more intensely human we are, the more we manifest that humanity to the people who really, really need our help the most, the more valuable that advice becomes.

So AI is going to keep making financial information dramatically better, faster, cheaper, and more accessible, and that’s all fantastic. Welcome it, because perhaps it will finally force our industry to confront a question that perhaps should have been confronted a long time ago. Are you providing information, or are you providing advice?

Those aren’t the same thing. Advice applies judgment. Information tells you what you can do. Advice is sometimes the trusted voice saying, “I wouldn’t do that if I were you.” And every once in a while, listening to that voice can save you from making perhaps one of the biggest financial mistakes of your life.

Have a great, great week, everybody.

More from Ben:
Fear Gets a Voice, Not a Vote
The Dominant Determinant: Why Investor Behavior Drives Real Results
Swim Coach or Lifeguard? Navigating Financial Rip Currents

-----------

Ben Beck is Managing Partner & Chief Investment Officer at Beck Bode, a deliberately different wealth management firm with a unique view on investing, business and life. Subscribe to his newsletter Relentless Abandon on LinkedIn.

Subscribe Now

Additional Reading